C&G Watch Star Trek

[charlesnaismith]

 

We have been watching Star Trek together for about 18 months now. Starting with TNG and now on TOS. I was able to get into it thanks to the viewing order recommandations on LetsWatchStarTrek. Unfortunately, our reviews and theirs are increasingly different. So C and I will do our own!

 

Below is the master list of TOS that we will gradually review and update. We are using the rating system from LetsWatchStarTrek, which is as follows:

1 = Bad. Only for the most dedicated fans.
2 = A mediocre episode, possibly worth skipping if new to Star Trek.
3 = Good! Generally enjoyable, worth watching if new to Star Trek.
4 = Great! An example of why we love Star Trek.
5 = One of the best. A classic.

Ratings will be listed C's rating | G's rating ie. 5|5 - we both thought it was awesome, 1|5 C hated it and G loved it.

Season One

The Man Trap Rating:
Charlie X Rating:
Where No Man Has Gone Before Rating:
The Naked Time Rating:
The Enemy Within Rating:
Mudd’s Women Rating:
What Are Little Girls Made Of? Rating:
Miri Rating:
Dagger of the Mind Rating:
The Corbomite Maneuver Rating:
The Menagerie, Part 1 Rating:
The Menagerie, Part 2 Rating:
The Conscience of the King Rating:
Balance of Terror Rating:
Shore Leave Rating:
The Galileo Seven Rating:
The Squire of Gothos Rating:
Arena Rating:
Tomorrow Is Yesterday Rating:
Court Martial Rating:
The Return of the Archons Rating:
Space Seed Rating:
A Taste of Armageddon Rating:
This Side of Paradise Rating:
The Devil in the Dark Rating:
Errand of Mercy Rating:
The Alternative Factor Rating:
The City on the Edge of Forever Rating:
Operation: Annihilate! Rating:

Season Two

Amok Time, Rating: 2|1 - some good moments but pretty bad overall
Who Mourns for Adonais, Rating: 3|2 - some bizarre and of it's time sexist banter, the plot was reasonable and the characters actions mean something
The Changeling, Rating: 3|3
Mirror, Mirror, Rating: 4|4
The Apple, Rating: 2|2
The Doomsday Machine, Rating: 4.5|5
Catspaw Rating:  1|0
I, Mudd Rating: 3|2
Metamorphosis Rating: -9001|1
Journey to Babel Rating: 4 (if edited)|4
Friday’s Child Rating:  3.5|3
The Deadly Years Rating: 3.5|3
Obsession Rating: 3|2
Wolf in the Fold Rating: 3|3
The Trouble With Tribbles Rating: 1|3
The Gamesters of Triskelion Rating: 0|1
A Piece of the Action Rating: 3|3.5
The Immunity Syndrome Rating: 5|3
A Private Little War Rating: 0|2
Return to Tomorrow Rating: 2|1
Patterns of Force Rating: 0|1
By Any Other Name Rating: 4|3.5
The Omega Glory Rating: 0|1
The Ultimate Computer Rating: 0.5|2
Bread and Circuses Rating: 1|1
Assignment: Earth Rating: 2|2

Season Three

Spock’s Brain Rating: 3.5|2
The Enterprise Incident Rating: 5|5
The Paradise Syndrome Rating:
And The Children Shall Lead Rating:
Is There in Truth No Beauty? Rating:
Spectre of the Gun Rating:
Day of the Dove Rating:
For the World is Hollow… Rating:
The Tholian Web Rating:
Plato’s Stepchildren Rating:
Wink of an Eye Rating:
The Empath Rating:
Elaan of Troyius Rating:
Whom Gods Destroy Rating:
Let That Be Your Last Battlefield Rating:
The Mark of Gideon Rating:
That Which Survives Rating:
The Light of Zetar Rating:
Requiem for Methuselah Rating:
The Way to Eden Rating:
The Cloud Minders Rating:
The Savage Curtain Rating
All Our Yesterdays Rating:
Turnabout Intruder Rating: